Love Butter? This Is the Upgrade.
The buttery taste you love, crafted with premium olive oil.
"We never thought we'd stop using butter... until we found this."
⚡ Today's Exclusive Bonus ⚡
FREE Garlic Olive Oil Sample (worth $12) + FREE Shipping
Added automatically at checkout - no code needed
Try It Out
200ml – Try it out
Perfect for first-time tasters
Smart Choice
200ml each – Smart choice
One for cooking, one for finishing
Best Deal
$110.97 →
200ml each · Save $30.98!
Why People Are Switching from Butter
This isn't a compromise — it's an upgrade.
Butter Infused Olive Oil is crafted by infusing high-quality olive oil with a natural plant-based butter flavour, creating a smooth, luxurious taste that feels indulgent while fitting beautifully into modern, health-conscious cooking.
People are genuinely surprised it's not butter.
Better for Everyday Cooking
Butter has its place — but for everyday use, many home cooks prefer olive oil.
A Smarter Fat Profile
Olive oil is naturally rich in monounsaturated fats, which are widely recognized as part of a balanced, heart-conscious diet — unlike butter, which is high in saturated fat.
Naturally Occurring Polyphenols
Extra virgin olive oil contains polyphenols, antioxidant compounds that help support overall wellness when enjoyed as part of a healthy lifestyle.
No Dairy. No Cholesterol. No Guilt.
All the flavour — without the heaviness.
Use It Anywhere You'd Use Butter
This is one of the most versatile oils in your kitchen.
Vegetables
Drizzle over roasted or steamed veggies
Bread
Dip warm crusty bread instead of butter
Pasta & Rice
Toss with hot noodles or grains
Seafood
Perfect for lobster, shrimp, scallops, or fish
Mashed Potatoes
Smooth, buttery flavour without dairy
Baking
Replace melted butter using ¾ cup oil for 1 cup butter
What Makes Muskoka Butter Olive Oil Different?
Made with premium olive oil and a natural butter flavour — no artificial additives.
A simple butter swap many people feel good about using every day.
Ideal for finishing, drizzling, light cooking, and baking.
What People Are Saying
Real feedback from people using it in their everyday cooking.
"I honestly can't believe how much it tastes like butter. I use it for everything now."
Sarah, ON
"I love that it gives me that buttery flavour without actually using butter."
Michael, BC
"It's become a staple in my kitchen — especially for veggies and pasta."
Jennifer, AB
"I feel better about using this every day, and the taste is amazing."
David, QC
"Once you try it, regular butter just doesn't hit the same."
Lisa, MB
"Perfect for cooking and finishing dishes. The flavor is incredible and I love that it's healthier."
Mark, NS
How It Compares
See why so many people are making the switch to Butter-Infused Olive Oil
| Butter | Butter-Infused Olive Oil | |
|---|---|---|
| Taste | Buttery | Rich buttery flavour |
| Made With | Dairy | Olive oil |
| Dairy-Free | ||
| Cholesterol | Contains | None |
| Everyday Use | Common | Designed for everyday cooking |
| Feel-Good Swap | — |
Don't Miss This Special Offer
Free Garlic Olive Oil Sample + Free Shipping
Offer ends soon - Limited inventory available
Join 3,247+ happy customers who've upgraded their cooking
Visit Us In Person
Prefer to shop in person? Find us at our stores across Ontario
Bracebridge
19 Taylor Road, Bracebridge ON P1L 1S6
📞 249 - 502 - 0967
Monday to Friday ~ 9:00am - 5:00pm
Saturday ~ 9:00am - 4:00pm
Sunday ~ Closed
Huntsville
58 Main Street East, Huntsville ON P1L 2B8
📞 705 - 787 - 0444
Sunday to Friday ~ 10:00am - 5:00pm
Saturday ~ 10:00am - 4:00pm